The four-month grandchild of football manager the former Manchester United defender died after he was placed in an “hazardous sleep posture” on his front by a maternity carer without official oversight, a coroner's investigation was told.
Madison Bruce Smith was found unresponsive by his dad, former footballer Matt Smith, at their home in Trafford last year.
The parents, Bruce's daughter Amy, had employed the maternity nurse via Ruthie Maternity Services under the impression she was skilled, trained and vetted and that the agency was reputable. Neither were subject to formal regulation.
Narrative Conclusion
In a formal finding at the coroner's court, the coroner stated “his cause of death could not be ascertained” after he was “put to sleep in a prone, unsafe position”.
Senior coroner for south Manchester the coroner issued a formal report to prevent future tragedies to the Health Secretary urging regulation.
Background to the Tragedy
The hearing heard Clements was employed after Madison had experienced problems sleeping in the afternoons.
Ruth Asare, head of the agency, said she had no medical qualifications and possessed only a first aid certificate and a diploma in post-natal care gained from a three-day course and a six-month coursework project.
Clements said she had a university degree in early years education but conceded she had no medical certifications.
“It is my hope these services will be regulated and, in the future, families are not placed in a situation where they think they are hiring a person who is qualified to guide them when they are evidently not qualified,” stated the senior coroner.
The court was told the infant's mother and father would “never have considered” of putting their son to sleep in the prone position but for the advice of the carer, who was said to have told them all four of her own babies had slept on their stomachs with no issues.
Such advice was contrary to established safe sleep advice from the National Health Service and medical experts for young babies.
‘Illusion of Qualification’
The coroner added the “supposed expertise” of untrained people posed a risk to infants where those services without oversight were used.
She went on: “We have been told that practically speaking any of us as while the term ‘registered nurse is tightly regulated, the term ‘nurse’ is not. It gives an illusion of someone who is highly trained and capable of supporting new parents.”
‘Precious Child’
She said Clements had been sleeping in another room and had responsibility for checking on the baby but, although he was heard through a monitor to stir a number of times during the night and had been crying, she had failed to go into his room.
The baby's mother and father, together with Bruce, who was at the time manager of Blackpool FC, and his son, former player Alex Bruce, were present at the hearing.
Ex-Manchester United defender Bruce was in charge of Blackpool at the time of the incident and missed the club's next match. In a message posted, he had said: “This has been the worst time of my family’s life and is something no parent should have to endure.”
In a testimony presented in court, the father said the couple's son was their “precious, perfect little boy”.
He said: “The loss of our son has been utterly excruciating. The pain is beyond words and often overwhelming. It has completely broken our entire family.”
He continued: “It is our firm belief that our son's death occurred in a total absence of regulation. In the absence of oversight such a tragedy will recur and more families will put their faith in individuals who should not be in the care of infants.”
Criminal Investigation
The coroner's court was informed the agency provided training on short courses for a cost of £450.
Asare told the coroner that those she instructed were given the safe sleeping advice to put babies on their backs to sleep.
However, the nurse said she had been taught by her to put babies in a prone position.
She rejected telling Madison's mother she was a nurse and also denied suggestions she had “convinced her” the prone position was safe.
The hearing was told police carried out an inquiry and detained the maternity nurse on suspicion of child neglect.
Detective Chief Inspector Matthew Dixon, of the police force, said the Crown Prosecution Service was consulted for directions and guidance, and it was identified that the threshold for criminal charges had not been met.
He said this was mainly because to the lack of regulation of such maternity services and that it was not against the law to put an infant on its stomach.
He added it could not be determined that Clements intended to wilfully harm the child.